Wednesday, June 13, 2007

Bad Idea Jeans Presents: Allowing Haitian U-17 Team Out Of Your Sights In NYC

When this is the alternative, sneaking out of JFK during a flight stopover must seem like a walk in the park.

"Yeah, I was going to wear a condom, but I figured, 'Hey, when am I going to be in Haiti again?'" VOICEOVER: "BAD IDEA JEANS"

Oh Haiti, will you ever win? If you're out and about today and tomorrow in New York City and happen to see half a dozen Haitians kicking a soccer ball down the street, well, the Haitian authorities would appreciate it if you would alert them. Apparently, half of the members of the Under 17 Haitian Soccer team deserted the team during a stopover at JFK today. Authorities believe that they received help from some Haitians already in NYC. Though it may not be humorous that teenagers are roaming the city illegally and the people who assisted them are technically criminals, the manner in which CnnSI "filled in the blanks" for the president of the Haitian Football Federation is pretty funny:
Yves Jean-Bart (president of the Haitian Football Federation) gave no indication why the players would abandon the team. But Haiti is the poorest country in the Western Hemisphere, and thousands of Haitians leave the country each year to escape miserable living conditions, violence and political instability.
CnnSI: "So Mr. Jean-Bart, any idea why your players deserted the team at JFK?"
Mr. Jean-Bart: "No. I have no idea."
CnnSI: "Could it have anything to do with the fact that Haiti is the poorest country in the Western Hemisphere, and thousands of Haitians leave the country each year to escape miserable living conditions, violence and political instability?"
Mr. Jean-Bart: "Well, when you put it that way..."

I'm no private detective nor am I trying to tell the police what to do but I'd start with cabs and gypsy cabs. Especially those blaring french language radio at obnoxious volumes. Even if those aren't the guys, could you ask them to turn the volume down. They never listen to me. Thanks.

The YES Network Is Run By A Bunch Of Liars

In any language the YES Network is lying about the Yanks' achievements.

In the Yanks most recent incarnation of their ridiculous advertisements featuring Michael Kay, some dramatic brass section and a cheesy phrase (previously "Pride... Power... Pinstripes" and "Looking back................................... Looking Forward") they have gone straight from cheese to straight fibbin. The commercial still involves the horns and Kay's voice, but today's version of the ad states:
"The New York Yankees; the most renowned sports franchise in the world have won more championships than any other team in the history of sports."
Actually guys, that's not factually correct. 26 championships for one team is a lot, I'll give you that. But it's far from the most. Just this past year, the West Genesee Wildcats won their 27th New York State Section 3 Lacrosse Championship. That's one more than the Yanks. Not to be outdone, the BU Terriers won their 28th Beanpot championship this past year. New Jersey's Delsea High School has won over 30 varsity football championships. Michigan's Albion College has won 30+ MIAA Championships in Baseball, Football and Track & Field. They've outdone the Yanks in three separate sports, including baseball. That's something. The Francis Parker School's Volleyball Team has won 44 championships under coach John Landicho. And as as of 2003, the Braybrook Redskins Basketball team had won 58 championships, over twice as many as the Yanks. I think you get the picture. The Yanks are good, 26 championships is a lot, but "the most championships in the history of sports....?" sirs, I call bullshit. Maybe next time they shouldn't hand their advertisement phrase-making responsibilities to an overzealous liar.

Not Re-Signing Orlando Cabrera May Go Down As The Worst Non-Signing In Baseball History

Ever since Game 4 of the World Series in 2004, the SS position for the Sox has been a 2.5 year, $50 million nightmare.

The 2004 season brings back a lot of memories. One of the earliest of those memories came on July 31st at around 5pm as I was sitting at my girlfriend's parent's dinner table when the Philly Sportscaster casually mentioned that Nomar Garciaparra had been traded for what seemed like at the time a ham sandwich and a case of Genny Cream Ale. In mid-bite of my hamburger I screamed some garbled obscenity that to this day is still perhaps the dirtiest thing I've ever said. As history has shown, Theo was right and I was wrong. But after watching Lugo kick around a few balls tonight and allowing another to get right passed him because he stepped the wrong way, it occurred to me that ever since the 2004 season ended, at least in terms of the shortstop position, it seems that the third party in Garciaparra - O-Cab / Mientl;kjsdfjaksl;cz deal was Faustus.

Following the success of the 2004 season and "the trade," Theo and his minions had a ton of roster collateral to work with. They had made so many smart moves to get the championship that you figured they'd just never make a bad move again. They could have re-signed Mo Vaughn and somehow Sox fans would have been ok with it. So when they overspent for Edgar Renteria (4 years for $40 million) instead of re-signing Orlando Cabrera because Cabrera wanted 4 years at around $30 million, you figured they knew what they were doing. They didn't. Renteria started slow and kept getting slower. Eventually his bat picked up and he was serviceable as a batting shortstop, but it was his defense that was really remarkable. In 2004, Renteria had 11 errors. In 2005, Renteria had 30 errors. And what made it so much more disappointing was that one of the major reasons for the Sox success (or Soxcess as the Herald has coined) in '04 was the vast improvement in middle infield D that Pokey Reese and O-Cab provided. So in response to the '04 Renteria disaster, the Sox traded Renteria for a prospect and agreed to pick up $11 million of the Renteria deal (essentially paying $19 million for one year of a 30 error SS play. Solid.) and then signed defensive whiz kid Alex Gonzales to fill the spot for the 2006 season. A-Gon put together mediocre numbers at the plate (though no worse than Renteria) but dazzled in the field, earning the Gold Glove award at SS for the AL.* It was widely known that A-Gon wasn't the solution and having traded away their best SS prospect (Hanley Ramirez) for Beckett the prior season, there was no young stud to come up and step in. The Sox had to go out and sign someone. They settled on Julio Lugo for 4 years and $36 million (an option for a 5th. I'm guessing they take the $1 million buyout.) and to date that decision has been as bad or worse than any front office move I have seen in any sport, business or fantasy league.

As of this very moment, Julio Lugo is batting 9th in the order (he was recently dropped to the 9th and replaced by a rookie in the leadoff spot. He was hitting behind Doug Mirabelli in his first trip to the 9 slot) and is hitting a robust .213. He has 18 stolen bases and hasn't been caught but he's been pretty horrendous in the field and his 8 errors and other fieldings stats don't seem to capture his incompetence in the field. He gave up the error in the fifth to kill Schilling's chance at a perfect game and he just seems to take bizarre routes to balls that appear playable. He also runs like a gimp. Simply stated: he's been shitty and looked shitty doing it. But none of this would matter if Orlando Cabrera (the one that got away) was also shitty. Unfortunately, that has not been the case.

Orlando Cabrera, in 2005, played SS for Anaheim, hit as many home runs as Renteria, struck out half as many times and stole twice as many bases. But the biggest difference was in the field. Cabrera made just 7 errors in all of 2005. Renteria had that many before the ground thawed out in beantown. The following year, while A-Gon struck out once every 6 at-bats, Cabrera hit .282 with 9 home runs, 71 RBI and 27 SBs and again played great D at SS. Now this year, Cabrera is hitting .332 with a .382 OBP and is again playing almost flawless D. Lugo, well like I said, Lugo is shitty. While all this information is good and explains why the Sox have failed in their quest to find a competent shortstop, none of the stats are more effective in making that point than this:

The Sox have spent $32 million on SS failures while Orlando Cabrera has outproduced all of the for a mere $22 million. That's an expensive non-signing. Thanks Theo. Oh, and about that Matt Clement deal....

*Derek Jeter actually won the award that year but considering he is one of the worst defensive shortstops in the league, I choose to disregard that mistake.

Tim Hardaway Will Not Be Working For A Military Defense Contractor


(This has little to nothing to do with sports. I just found it too amusing to go untold (or un-re-told).)

Tim Hardaway may not want anything to do with gay people, but apparently our military contractors are suggesting that their ability to turn on the "gay switch" will help us win the war on terror. On the Washington Post's website, a story was told about a proposed "gay bomb" that the military proposed using to fight terrorists:
[a military watchdog group uncovered a] "U.S. military proposal to create a hormone bomb that could purportedly turn enemy soldiers into homosexuals and make them more interested in sex than fighting."

The proposal came from the Air Force's Wright Laboratory in Dayton, Ohio, which requested $7.5 million to develop a so-called "gay-bomb." Using the Freedom of Information Act, Edward Hammond, director of the U.S. office of the Sunshine Project, obtained a copy which was "part of a military effort to develop non-lethal weapons." If completed, the bomb would release a chemical aphrodisiac "and by virtue of either breathing or having their skin exposed to this chemical... soldiers would become gay." This would cause their units to break down as the troops "became irresistibly attractive to one another." In addition to a "gay bomb" the proposal also mentions using chemicals which could make bees angry so that enemy forces would be attacked not only by our troops but also swarms of stinging insects.
I think that's the same hormone released by fat chicks after 3am. Any male who has ingested more than 8 drinks is helpless against their "chemical aphrodisiac." I do like the bee idea though. To me, forcing people to deal with a group of angry bees seems much more effective than forcing dudes to make out. The only question I have is are the bees in the bomb? I don't think bees hang out in the deserts or mountain ranges of these terrorists. Wouldn't the bees be angry enough if we forced them to sit in a bomb for a long period of time and then exploded them on an area where bees aren't normally located? That would make me angry.

Tuesday, June 12, 2007

Shockey's Overrated? No He's Not, KC Joyner

I bet hanging out with that chick is overrated. She's a fucking bucksnort.

This is an open letter to KC Joyner and will meander from the direct questions to Joyner to third person inquiries directed at Joyner (a unique writing style, I know). KC, I welcome your retort and apologize for the language:

I am no fan of the New York Giants nor am I a big fan of Jeremy Shockey (I actually hate him), so as I begin writing this I can't help but think of the line from Top Gun when Stinger has Goose and Mav in his office and is about to tell them they're going to Miramar and says: "I gotta do something here, I still can't believe it." While Stinger couldn't believe he had to send Goose and Mav to Top Gun, similarly I can't believe I gotta defend Jeremy Shockey. Unfortunately after KC Joyner's out of the blue shot at Shockey, I feel compelled to speak out.

ESPN.com's KC Joyner has apparently been asked to create a list of the most overrated and underrated players in the NFL. He started with Tight Ends and presumably because Randy McMichael, Chris Cooley and Desmond Clark weren't big enough names for him, he called out Jeremy Shockey:
Jeremy Shockey
Shockey was a Pro Bowl alternate last year, but the metrics indicate he didn't deserve the selection. Shockey ranked 23rd in yards per attempt among qualifying tight ends last year (5.6). He ranked last in medium pass YPA and 18th in short pass YPA.

Shockey is perceived to be an excellent downfield threat when lining up as a wide receiver, but that is also a mirage. He had a 4.7 YPA on passes thrown to him when he was flexed out, a total that placed him next to last in that category.

In a nutshell, Shockey's YPA figures place him more in the company of Randal Williams and Alex Smith, not Jason Witten and Alge Crumpler (the other two NFC Pro Bowl tight ends in 2006).
A couple things that strike me about this. First, KC describes his method of comparison as this: "The criteria I used was contrasting the player's 2006 metrics with his perceived performance level." Ohhhhh sure, we just measure the metrics against the PPL, or Perceived performance level. But Joyner doesn't give us the metrics for the entire league and funny, the PPL doesn't show up in KC Joyner's glossary and Joyner chooses not to define it throughout the rest of his post. So that means a player's perceived performance level could mean anything. Does it mean that we expect Shockey to catch 80 balls a year because he's a star in the league and his name is recognizable because he's in a big market and is flashy? Or does it mean his actual projected performance level based on previous years. If that's the case, you could argue Shockey outperformed his previous Pro Bowl years of 02-03, 03-04 & 05-06. I mean he had more receptions than all but one of his previous years and tied for the most touchdowns he's had in one season in his career. If you were going to project Jeremy Shockey for 06-07, 66 catches and 7 TDs would be about where you'd probably expect him to be. So my question is then: WHAT THE FUCK DOES "PERCEIVED PERFORMANCE LEVEL MEAN?" If it can mean anything you want it to, then that's fine. KC Joyner is leading my stat for perceived fictitious stat manufacturing.

Even if we are to disregard the mysterious PPL, the other stats Joyner chooses to use are completely meaningless in the context of his post. Joyner says that "Shockey is perceived to be an excellent downfield threat when lining up as a wide receiver, but that is ... a mirage." Shockey is not "an excellent downfield threat" when he's lined up outside. He's a matchup problem. When Shockey lines up wide or in the slot he's not out there to beat a corner, safety or linebacker down the field on a fucking "go route" (especially after he tweaked his ankle. In fact, all his low yardage numbers are likely due to his ankle injury, but I'll explain that later.), he's there so he won't get double teamed or as easily chucked like he would if he were to lineup in front of a D-End or linebacker. It's a mismatch issue, not a speed issue. If they lineup a corner against him, he'll post them up. If they put a linebacker on him, he'll try and out-quick him and create space on the sideline or down the seam. And if they have to bring a safety over to man him up, well then Plaxico will likely have more space on his deep routes because they'll only have one guy over the top to deal with him. So to say that Shockey is fails as a perceived "deep threat" is absurd.

Second (you could argue that this is actually "third" or "fourth," but I'm goin with "second"), what kind of stats are you using? If Shockey is overrated, shouldn't he be underproducing in stats that people expected him to produce, like TDs or receptions? Well, for TEs, he had the third most TDs (and as many TDs as Chad Johnson), the fifth most receptions amongst TEs (2 more than the aforementioned Witten) and only Gates and Gonzales caught more passes for first downs and Shockey easily had the highest POCTRIFDRINFLG of any of the TES with more than 60 catches (POCTRIFDRINFLG = percentage of catches that resulted in first downs in NFL games. Two can play the "made up stat" game, KC). Aren't those the stats we expect year in and year out for Shockey? No one goes into the year thinking Shockey is going to have a big year because he should be able to get his YPA over 7.5 in the slot position. And if no one expects that or uses YPA to "rate" a player going into a season, then there's no way it can be used to prove a player is overrated. Lastly, with regards to YPA, what the fuck does YPA by itself prove? Does it prove that Shockey is overrated, that Shockey is underused or that Eli Manning fucking blows (HINT: It's the last one). If you ever watch a game (and I've read that you do), you must realize that Eli Manning is one of the worst QBs in the NFL and is at least half if not 3/4 of any issue that Shockey may have in terms of production.

Third, it is really lame to pick a year in which Shockey was injured and use those stats to prove he's overrated and then not discuss how these stats differ from his previous years. If his YPA was low this past year but his career YPA is high every other year (and again I have no idea because you do not provide the reader with any of the information), then he's not overrated, it's likely he just suffered an injury and wasn't as explosive as previous years. But judging by the fact that his Yards Per Reception were also down by about 3 yards over his previous career average, I'm going to go with a down year due to injury. It seems you're just picking on a weaker kid. And why? BECAUSE HE COULDN'T RUN VERY FAST (in 2006).

Fourth, when you give us these "metrics," it would be nice if you could give us the metrics for all TEs in 2006. The reason being that while I believe you that Shockey's 4.7 YPA--in the all-important category of TE YPA when flexed out stat--was good enough for second to last in the NFL, I have no idea whether the tenth best flexed out YPA was 4.9 or 9.9. And that matters because, well you can probably figure out why. Because it is such an obscure and meaningless stat, it only matters if Shockey is abnormally worse than everyone else, like off the charts (and even then it doesn't matter to anyone but you).

Fifth, you may need Shockey in your post to make it more interesting, but you need to do better than YPA and flexed out YPA if you want to make the point your headline suggest that you are making. If you're going to use those stats, explain to me why they matter. I consider myself a pretty bright guy, but I can't for the life of me figure out why Shockey's low YPA makes a shit of difference in terms of how he is "rated" when he rates so high in so many other TE stats during a year in which he was not even close to 100%. If you want me to believe that prior to 2006 the stat nerds thought Shockey's YPA was going to be over 9 this year and he disappointed, well then that's great and I buy it. The headline of your post could then have been "Shockey's YPA In 2006 Was Lower Than Some Other TEs And Yet He Made The Pro Bowl Because He Had Many Touchdowns And Also Because A Player's YPA Is Not Determinative Of Anything." Next time let that be your your point and no one will read it because no one cares.

Lastly, where exactly is Shockey rated in a more general sense of ranking TEs? He's probably a top 5 TE in terms of offensive production. He's less athletic then some less productive guys like Ben Watson and Kellen Winslow, but he is a smarter player than either of them. I would say that Jeremy Shockey is a Pro Bowl caliber player who will never be the best TE in the league and is a bit injury prone. And because he is rated like that, so far, he's never disappointed.

Other than that I really liked what you wrote. Congrats, idiot.

Warmest Regards,
LD

Monday, June 11, 2007

The AL MVP Is A Two Horse Race.... And The Horses Are Closer Than You May Think

If you don't know much about Dan Haren, this picture will give you all you need to know. He likes puppies and dudes.

It would be difficult to argue that anyone other than A-Rod even has a prayer in the AL MVP race. If you want to argue that Mags has a shot, I say A-Rod has almost double the homers and Mags has given way to Sheffield recently in terms of who is carrying the team. Plus, Ordonez will likely get hurt and miss too much time to garner much consideration. If you're taking Vlad, I'd have to listen a little longer because while that lineup as a whole is pretty solid, Vlad is clearly the only consistent threat on that team and without his production and stability the Angels would not be in contention. The only problem with the argument is that Vlad is in a tough division and with A-Rod so far ahead in terms of numbers, Vlad would have to step up his production a bit and the Angels would have to win the division in order for him to improve his candidacy enough to have a shot. Ortiz, well, that's an argument for another day but if he couldn't win in 2005 (or even garner serious consideration last year), he'll likely never win. But there is one guy who is having a year that is so outstanding and so important to his team's success that he is not only worthy of conisderation for AL MVP, he'd get my vote if we were voting today (admittedly this has something to do with my dislike of A-Rod AND my strongly-held belief that pitchers are undervalued in the MVP debate).

Oakland's Dan Haren isn't just having a good year, he's on pace to put together the best season by an AL pitcher since they lowered the mound. In order to properly recognize just how outstanding a season Dan Haren is having, you first must discount what Jake Peavy is doing in the National League as he is the only player in the majors with comparable numbers. Distinguishing Peavy is pretty easy. He plays in the National League and in the National League they play Tee Ball. To give you an idea of just how bad the lineups in the NL are, Peavy's team, the National League West leading Pads, is hitting Josh Bard in their cleanup spot. In 147 ABs, Bard has 2Hrs, 18RBI and has an OPS of .661. Carlos Zambrano has an OPS of .740. When talking about stellar pitching, unless an NL pitcher has an ERA below 1.00, they are having an average year. Haren on the other hand, is out of control. First, he plays in the real Major Leagues so his stats are official and second, if he were to finish the year with at his present ERA (1.58) it would be the lowest ERA since the Big Train Walter Johnson in 1919. And back then they actually batted with their fingers and the ball they used was made of granite because twine and rawhide had been used up for the war.* It would seem that Johnson had a bit of an advantage given that he was capable of throwing at or near 100mph, or so they say. But to truly understand what Haren is doing, you've got to look a little deeper.

I think it'd be fair to say that the high water mark for pitching in the modern era was Pedro Martinez in 1999. At the height of the "steroid era," Petey started 29 games, won 23 games, lost 4, threw 233 innings, struck out 313, walked 37 (strikeout to walk ratio over 8. Pedro's the only pitcher in AL history to record such a feat. And he's done it twice.), had an ERA of 2.02 and gave up 9 home runs. 9. To put that in perspective, since Johan Santana has taken the reins as the AL's best pitcher, the fewest home runs he's given up in a year is 22 (he gave up 17 in 2003 but only pitched 158 innings. He's given up 13 already this year.). But what was most amazing about that year was just how much better than everyone else Pedro was. The second best ERA was David Cone at 3.44. He had 100 more strikeouts than the next guy. And he had 5 more wins than the next guy. While Haren may not end the season with the K numbers or have 5 more wins than anyone, the comparison to Pedro's '99 season is fair in terms of just how much better a season he's having than every other pitcher in the AL.

Haren's 1.58 ERA is not only the lowest ERA in almost 100 years but it's almost a full run lower than the next closest guy (who happens to be his teammate, Chad Gaudin at 2.43). He's only given up more than 2 runs once (3 runs to he Yanks in a game he won) and has given up 1 run or less in 8 of his 14 starts, including 4 games where he gave up no runs. Opponents are hitting .179 against him. The next lowest is more than 30 points higher at .211. His opponents on base percentage is an absurd .227, a mere 30 points lower than the next closest and opponents OPS is .513. That's 60 points lower than the next closest pitcher and 150 points lower than the 10th lowest OPS in the AL. He doesn't have killer strikeout numbers like '99 Pedro, but he's still amongst the league leaders in K/9 and K/BB ratio. Because his ERA and opponents batting average are at historic lows, the fact that he's not striking out as many people as one of the greatest of all-time shouldn't obscure the fact that he is so much better than every other pitcher in the game that his performance warrants MVP consideration.

Unfortunately for Haren, he has multiple factors working against him. First, he pitches in Oakland. If he were pitching in New York or Boston, his number would be retired and songs would be sung about him. And because of this relative lack of exposure, he will likely fail to lead many ballots when they are cast (assuming that against all odds Haren is able to keep this pace up). He also is playing in a very tough division and the ONLY chance he has is if Oakland wins the AL West and Haren wins 20+ games. Both of which are unlikely. My guess for what Haren would have to finish the season at in order to compete with A-Rod is 22-3, 1.85 ERA, perhaps a couple complete game shutouts and maybe a photo with two or three Canadian strippers. Again, it's very unlikely that Haren will be able to keep this up but what's more important is that Haren's year not be obscured just because players like A-Rod are hitting the cover off the ball, or just because A-Rod likes strippers that resemble men.

*Information about baseball equipment in 1919 may not necessarily be factually correct.

When Scott Baio Ruled The World

Howard Cosell calling Baio's run through an obstacle course. God Bless you YouTube.

(Baio's run is a little after the halfway mark. Do NOT fastforward the pre-race interview with Baio. Especially if you've ever been interested in seeing Scott Baio's balls. Not that that's the only reason to watch or the reason I like the video or.... let's just move on.)

This original design for this post, more than anything, was simply to present a glorified advertisement for Scott Baio's upcoming reality show on VH1 entitled: "Scott Baio is 45 ... and Single." I was going to tie in sports somehow (maybe a Charles in Charge episode or something), but really I wanted to talk about how amazed I was that the mighty Baio had fallen so far and stooped to such a level of ignomity by allowing his lovelife to be taped and broadcast for all to see. But then, by the grace of the 'Tube, I was rewarded with the above video. I really don't have the words to describe it but I think it's safe to say that Scott Baio was a frickin stud back in the day. He DOMINATED that obstacle course. He must've snuck onto the course the night before and practiced. The video would be great solo, but to have Howard Cosell do the play-by-play.... how is this not in the YouTube hall of fame?

Anyhoo, back to Baio's show. The concept for the show itself is enticing but the previews were what really drew me in. Baio, it would seem, has an aversion to commitment that borders on a clinical disorder. It's a pretty pathetic setup and the preview shows clips of him arguing with his girlfriend and then later at a strip club (the juxtaposition is meant to suggest that the two cannot co-exist. Well, it's working ok for A-Rod...). My favorite part (other than the fact that it caused me to stumble upon the above video) is that Baio is clearly in denial about just how weak a move this is. He offers this, ummm, defense(?) of the show and why he's doing it:
"I didn't want to do a reality show. The concepts were always meaningless, and the people seemed pathetic," Baio says. "Maybe I'm a little pathetic. But this isn't Scott Baio getting a colonoscopy. It's about a guy trying to get his life together, trying to figure out why he's never been married and what his problem is."
I know I'll be watching but maybe Scott should think about doing a better job of getting the key demo's attention here. I'm not sure, "Scott Baio is 45 ... and Single; at least it's better than watching a colonoscopy" is going to get people watching.

I'm No Doctor, But Julian Tavarez Is Bat-Shit Crazy


It's pretty well known that Julian Tavarez is a weird dude. Aside from bearing a distinct resemblance to Freddy Kruger, he has been involved in many a dustup due to his hair trigger temper, admits to buying new clothes as opposed to washing his dirty clothes and recently told the Globe that if baseball didn't work out for him, he wanted to be a porn star. But one of his more pronounced "quirks" is his penchant for self-treating his ailments via "home remedy" (The Herald wrote a piece about this a couple months ago. Subscription required.). He actually uses Snake Oil to keep his joints loose though he admits that he's pretty sure it has no effect. That's all well and good because pitchers are a superstitious and regimented bunch, but his most recent treatment seems a little wacky even for Julian. In treating a blister on his pitching hand, Julian has chosen the remedy that so many other 21 year-old chicks in tight pants choose when they want to stay out later and get drunker: Red Bull.

Tavarez said he pops the blister and dries it out by rubbing in some Red Bull and ground-up aspirin.
Red Bull and aspirin. That seems, uh, healthy...? But this wouldn't be a Julian Tavarez story without some kind of bizarre and unnecessary comment. In describing just how bad the blister is, Tavarez said:
"[Josh ] Beckett would be on the DL with this"

Nice, JT.

Friday, June 8, 2007

So Why Is Mel Kiper Not a GM? I Give You Robert Meachem

Meachem relaxes on a bench on the campus of the University of Tennessee.

By now it must seem that I have some sort of vendetta against Mel Kiper as this is at least the 5th post featuring a knock of Mel. The truth is that I don't have a problem with him or his job (in fact, I'm very envious of his position), I just feel that he is never held accountable for the asinine things he says year in and year out. Mel Kiper, above all, is an information gatherer. He watches tape, attends games in weird places, talks to a ton of people in "the biz" and waxes his ass hairs (I'm not positive about the last one, but I think it's fair to guess that he does.). He IS NOT A TALENT SCOUT! He gives you information about the players that no one else knows about. He knows their strengths and weaknesses but HE HAS NO IDEA HOW THOSE WILL TRANSLATE TO THE NFL. If he did, he would be working for an NFL team. The only people he is qualified to "rate" are the top 10 guys, and by the time the draft rolls around YOU AND I COULD F'N DO THAT! So I find it humorous that he is given the job of trying to project who will be good and who will stink considering that's not really his job (though he takes it on with gusto). So with this in mind, I've found the kickoff to the Robert Meachem experience (A Mel Kiper favorite) particularly enjoyable.

You may recall that Kiper had Meachem rated very high amongst the wide receiver crop. Kiper also felt that he NEEDED to go to Tennessee. When Tennessee skipped Meachem in favor of safety Michael Griffin of Texas, well, let's just say that Mel disapproved:
Vince Young needed help at wide receiver, and the Titans had Robert Meachem staring right at them. Michael Griffin is a nice safety, but he was a luxury pick and the Titans couldn't afford to take a safety when they needed help at other positions...

The Tennessee Titans desperately needed help at wide receiver and could have used a defensive end. Instead, with the 19th pick in the first round, they took Texas safety Michael Griffin. He's not that versatile and can't play cornerback despite being 5-11½, 205 pounds. They took Griffin when wide receivers Robert Meachem and Dwayne Bowe were still available.
But Mel doesn't stop there, "He's not that versatile and can't play cornerback despite being 5-11½, 205 pounds." Well Mel, not exactly. Upon entering Titans camp, Griffin was immediately moved to cornerback (I can't emphasize this enough, Mel doesn't get the talent translation thing). I also like that Mel praised New Orleans for the pick when they had one of the tend worst rusn defenses in the league and didn't take Durant or David Harris. And while Mel couldn't have foreseen what has gone on since the draft, if he's the super scout he claims to be, maybe he could have followed Meachem to the buffet line:
"He struggled some. He had some blisters on his feet, and he's overweight. Today, he tweaked his ankle a little bit during the morning practice. It hasn't been all roses for him. He's been on that first-round tour that these guys go on where they visit all these teams and eat all these fun dinners. And it looks like it right now. So he's got a ways to go."

Meachem agreed his pre-draft schedule hurt his conditioning, "I think I had like nine visits or so. And every visit they give you a big old meal. So for me, I tried to work out when I could, but I don't think I got enough workouts in."
Fortunately for Mel (and Meachem), many players have come in out of shape and worked out fine because the offseason workouts are so demanding. Marques Colston for instance:
"Meachem said, 'He (Marques) talked to me and he told me he probably got in his best shape during offseason workouts between rookie camp and training camp. It gave me a little confidence.'"
Well, that's good. Meachem will be ship shape by the time training camp rolls around. What? He's not going to be able to participate in the offseason workout because he just had surgery to repair a recurring knee injury you say? And the doctors are as optimistic about this surgery as they were the last time a doctor performed the same surgery (which flared up less than 4 years later). Well, at least with the power of positive thinking Meachem can get through this:
"I kind of feel discouraged a little bit because I want to show the coaches what I can do and you can't show them what you can do when you're hurt," Meachem said Wednesday. "For me, it's going to be a time I've got to keep praying and just stay focused - don't let the knee injury get to me."
Robby, you might want to add "....and stay away from the Gumbo" to your list of things you need to do over the next 6 months. Good call on this one Mel. The Titans must be really upset they passed on a chronically injured fat kid with motivation problems and an overeating disorder.

Wednesday, June 6, 2007

Mike Lowell - Renaissance Man


Take a look at these two players and there numbers so far this year:

Player A: Avg: .330, 17 2b, 11 HR, 45 RBI, 17 Ks, OBP: .385, SLG%: .574, OPS: .959

Player B: Avg. .292, 11 2b, 12 HR, 33 RBI, 20 Ks, OBP: .378, SLG%: .517, OPS: .894

Clearly player A is having the better year but to put his statistics in context, player A is in the top ten for Home Runs, 6th in RBI, 9th in average, 6th in OPS and in 200+ ABs, he's only struck out 17 times. That's lowest strikeout rate amongst players in the top 25 OPS. Player A is Mike Lowell and player B is Albert Pujols.

Now the reason I offer Pujols as a comparison is because A.) It's a big name and is an attention drawer (though I am in NO WAY suggesting that Mike Lowell is the hitter that Pujols is. I'm merely juxtaposing their stats for the purpose of showing the outstanding year Lowell is having this year.); and B.) Pujols, while not having a huge year, is still on pace to hit near .300, drive in 100 runs and hit 35 Home Runs; which means that Lowell is on pace for even bigger things this year. Regardless of how he ends up, he's having a hell of a year and he is one of the major reasons that Manny was able to start slow, Ortiz was able to go 60 ABs without a home run, JD Drew is able to fly under the radar and the Red Sox are able to continue winning. These are things you can find in the Box Score, but there is much more to Lowell than merely his stats. Here are a few other things that Lowell has done or does:

Lowell is a cancer survivor. In 1999, he was diagnosed with testicular cancer while in Spring Training. He came back to play in May of that year and won the Tony Canigliaro Award as the player who best overcomes an obstacle or adversity.

Lowell HATES Fidel Castro. Last year after Castro became sick, Lowell, the son of a Cuban refugee, was asked what he thought about Castro's illness said, “Castro killed members of my family... I hope he does die.”

Lowell was one of the Sox who hit 4 home runs in a row on April 22nd.
But what I found most interesting about Lowell was this little ditty in Gammo's latest column about Lowell making promises to a dead girl's family:

On April 20, Courtney Butcher of Worcester, Mass., a freshman at the University of New Hampshire, called her father, Jim, to talk about the Monster seats Jim had purchased for the family for the Sunday night game. Lowell was her favorite player. That night, right after Courtney talked to her father, she and three friends were killed in an automobile accident. That Sunday night, Jim took his other children to the game. In the 4-HR inning, Lowell's shot went right to the Butcher family.

The next day, a friend of the family called Sarah Stevenson of the Red Sox, who relayed the message to Lowell, and he signed a uniform with these words: "Courtney, May God Be With You, Rest in Peace." He also sent word to Jim Butcher that he would homer for Courtney. The wake was that Tuesday, April 24, and Lowell's uniform was draped over Courtney's coffin. That night, he homered against the Blue Jays.
Ewwwwwwww K. A couple things about this disturb me about this (not the least of which being that their daughter died in a tragic car accident on the 20th and the family was at a baseball game on the 22nd), but how about Lowell pulling the Babe Ruth / Paul O'Neill via Kramer in Seinfeld move. I don't know, maybe it's just me but I'm not promising a grieving family a Home Run even if I'm playing home run derby in a little league park. Those people are clearly not dealing with this very well and Lowell's move, had it not worked out, would not have helped. I guess this is proof positive that this year he can do no wrong.

The True Story About The Importance of The Standings In June

It makes me sad to think that there are college graduates reading this who were not alive when the above season ended.

If you pay attention to the coverage of Major League Baseball, you've likely heard folks talk about how the Red Sox have the AL East wrapped up and the rest of the AL East is playing for the Wild Card. There are a couple of things that bother me about this. One of them is that in NY, people say this because secretly they believe the Sox are going to blow the lead and when they do they will use this lead as ammo that the Sox "blew the lead." This is a common sports pundit move. It makes good copy to take a such a hard-line stance about something, plus you lower the expectations of your base so that if their team makes any kind of charge, it looks good. Being a Sox fan I am all too familiar with this ploy. The other problem I have with this talk is that a 10+ game swing in the standings from June to October is not all that uncommon.

Last year on June 6th, Minnesota was back 11.5 games from Detroit. On October 1, Minnesota was up 1 on Detroit. I don't think I heard about Detroit's "collapse" that year. Also last year, Texas was up 3.5 on Oakland on June 6th. As of October 1, Texas was 13 back of the AL West leading A's. Let's just say that the headline in the Fort Worth Star-Telegram's Sports Section on October 2nd was not RANGERS DROP 16.5 GAMES IN STANDINGS BETWEEN JUNE 1st AND OCTOBER 1st. In the NL West, Arizona was leading that division by a 1.5 games on June 6th. By October 1st, they were 13 games back. And the Sox themselves dropped 11.5 games in the standings last year between June 1st and October 1st. So to put that into context, of the 4 division winners who were not in first on June 1st, the team that eventually won the division last year ended up making up an average of about 13.5 games over the team that was in the lead as of June 1st. So it was more likely that a team in first as of June 1st would lose 10+ games in the standings to the division eventual winner than not. Essentially that means that the only teams mathematically eliminated are Kansas City and Texas.

So when you think about it, if the Yanks made up the (as of right now) 11 games, not only would it really not be that big a deal, it's almost predictable. It's more likely than not that the Sox will slip 10 games to the eventual leader by year's end. In fact, the Yankees would be an abject failure if they did not make up 13 games between now and October 1st. A joke if you will (see what I did there? If don't see it, re-read my first gripe about why the current standings are being talked about so much. Yes, I know. I'm very clever.).

A D-Bag Goes To The D-League

Well, looks like Quin really landed on his feet after that Mizzou debacle, eh?

As mentioned in my profile, I have a irrational hatred for Quin Snyder. He's just one of those guys that people hate just by looking at them. My dad hated a Northern New York weatherman named Tom Messner, a friend of mine has a similar loathing for Andy Garcia and a friend of mine's dad hates Alan Thicke (no word on how he feels about Thicke's falsetto singing son). To be honest, if you asked my why I feel so strongly about him, I could not possibly explain it. I will tell you, however, that while I can't explain it, I sure can feel it, and the sensation of hatred is palpable and real (as few know, the original name for this blog was "Can't Stand Quin Snyder," and that was during a period of time where Quin was neither seen nor heard, unless were around a meth lab or high school party near Mercer Island, Washington). Anyhoo, it was announced today that our friend Quin did what other former disgraced college coaches have done before him (see Jim Harrick), he signed with the D-League's Austin Toros. It is gonna be just too sweet knowing that Quin will be taking the Team van to Motel 6's in rockin towns like Fort Wayne, Bismarck and Albuquerque. I will really enjoy this while it lasts. But what I find most ironic about the situation is that Quin, a disgraced coach who broke several rules while in the college game, is joining a team with a bit of a scandalous past itself:
The mascot, known as Da Bull, prematurely ran onto the court and hung from the rim with .4 seconds remaining, apparently to punctuate center Loren Woods' breakaway dunk that gave the Toros a four-point lead over Colorado.

While hanging from the rim, the Toros detailed in a news release Thursday, Da Bull collided with a Colorado player. At the point of contact, the mascot's head, to his horror, fell to the floor.

The Toros were assessed a technical foul. The 14ers' Von Wafer made the free throw, but Rick Rickert missed a 3-pointer that would have tied the score as time expired.

"I was hanging there in celebration," Da Bull said. "I didn't see the ball in play."

Da Bull was suspended for two games and assigned by the team to 50 hours of community service. A replacement mascot will perform in his absence; Da Bull is expected to return to duty Feb. 2 when the Toros play the Bakersfield Jam.
Unfortunately for Quin, Mizzou wasn't so understanding. But it got me thinking that maybe there was more to this hiring than just using Quin's tremendous marketing cache. Maybe this team wants to emulate the fiery "no holds barred" style of "Da Bull" and hired Quin as an extension of this new attitude. Da Bull and Quin seem to have a lot in common. Given that this seems like more than a coincidence, I thought it might be interesting to compare the two. Well fortunately, the Toros have a "Da Bull Bio" on their site. So how closely does Quin compare to Da Bull?

Da Bull: Height: 6-2
Quin: Height: 6-3

Da Bull: Shoe Size: 13
Quin: Shoe Size: 7

Da Bull: Favorite Color: Toros Blue and Red
Quin: Favorite Color: Powder White

Da Bull: Favorite Foods: ALL
Quin: Favorite Foods: Chicken and Cock Sandwich, hold the chicken

Da Bull: Favorite Book: How To Be the Best Mascot In The Game
Quin: Favorite Book: The Secret

Da Bull: Favorite Music: Hip Hop
Quin: Favorite Music: Genesis after '78

Da Bull: Favorite Hangout: The Austin Convention Center otherwise known as “Da Bull Pen”
Quin: Favorite Hangout: Parking lots of high school dances and the cold medicine sections of CVS

Da Bull: Favorite Actress: Sandra Bullock (She lives in Austin too!)
Quin: Favorite Actress: RuPaul

Da Bull: Role Model: San Antonio Spurs Coyote
Quin: Role Model: Caligula

Da Bull: Attitude towards life: Da Bull loves to create excitement. He is 100% pure energy. He likes to pass this energy to everyone around him.
Quin: Attitude towards life: Fuck it, they'll never find out...

Da Bull: Response to audience: Da Bull loves people, especially children!
Quin: Response to audience: "Tell 'chesty' in section 12, row 3, that I'm in room 102 at the Super 8 right off I-40 next to the Waffle House. And tell her I'll make it rain if she makes it snow."

Da Bull: Pet Peeves: When people pull on DA BULL’S TAIL!!!!
Quin: Pet Peeves: Narcs

Da Bull: Hobbies: Da Bull loves to play games and be active and he also loves cars
Quin: Hobbies: Needlepoint

Best of luck Quin.

Tuesday, June 5, 2007

Sports Guy v. Cowherd: An ESPN Family Feud

The pre-Louie Anderson version of "The Feud".

This could get good folks. We may have a legitimate feud on our hands here from two ESPN personalities who can't help themselves but comment about the other's work. If you read Simmons's blog yesterday, you may have seen the line about ESPN radio's Colin Cowherd about 3/5 the way down. And the beauty of it is that he didn't just kind of politely correct him or point out some flaws in Herd's argument, he pretty much told him to F off. And what's even better than that is that there is NO WAY that Cowherd doesn't respond today. But if you're not following, allow me to set the scene:

After Kobe told the world he wanted to be traded, Simmons posted a list of possible trade partners for the Lakers. He explained that it would be very difficult to make a deal but not impossible. To Simmons credit, no one I read has a better grasp of the inner workings of the NBA's salary cap, how salaries match up and the value of the expiring contract. So while I could give a shit about the NBA, I trust Simmons knows what he's talking about. But in viewing the trades, I was struck that none of them looked all that remarkable. The best one, the Shawn Marion deal, even seemed a little light for arguably the best scorer of his generation. But then again, I don't think Simmons was suggesting that the Lakers should make any of these deals, he was simply pointing out deals that he felt could be made. Well, then came Cowherd...

The Herd is not exactly a fan favorite in the blogosphere to begin with. He's notorious for blatantly ripping off material from blogs without giving them credit and was excoriated by ESPN's ombudsman and forced to apologize on air for telling people to rush to The Big Lead and crash the site (which they successfully did). After the Kobe rant and Simmons's post, Herd spent most of his show telling his listeners that there's no way a Kobe deal was going to happen and that all of the Simmons trade scenarios were absurd. He went through most of them and his argument was that none of the names were big enough to warrant a Kobe deal. He kinda pegged Simmons as a basketball nerd (though I think his intention was to give credit to Simmons's knowledge of the NBA) and his point was that if these are the best deals that ESPN's resident NBA geek can come up with, then there's no chance he is getting traded. I didn't find it to be anti-Simmons and in fact kind of found it to be an extension of what Simmons had written about. Apparently Bill didn't see it that way.

Yesterday, Simmons wrote that Cowherd was lazy and that he didn't read the entire post. He basically called him an idiot for not understanding Simmons main points and then went on to say that Cowherd "embarrassed himself by not understanding basic NBA trading principles". But my favorite was that without a hint of irony, Simmons, a blogger, took a not-so-subtle dig at Cowherd's profession as a radio personality and how because the job is so easy you should never make the mistake of being misinformed, and then was misinformed about Herd's show himself:
Your show's on for three hours a day and you get four giant commercial breaks per hour. That leaves you plenty of time to research your segments so you don't come off as misinformed. No offense.
No offense Bill, but Cowherd's show airs for 4 hours. You would think that during ONE OF YOUR THREE GIANT COMMERCIAL BREAKS during your mid-morning viewing of the previous night's episode of the Inferno on your TiVo you could have researched Cowherd's show and learned how long it is on the air. No offense.

ESPN doesn't really like infighting, but these two "rabble-rousers" are too popular to be tamed and their egos are too big to stand down. So I say, "Colin, your response?"

(UPDATE: Herd responded and said pretty much what I said. He really held back from responding in his usual more combative manner. Pretty weak, though it was enough that Simmons will be forced to offer some sort of surreply that will likely be some kind of smug half-apology. I'm holding out hope that Simmons rips Colin again because there's no way Colin's response to that would be as cordial.)

Monday, June 4, 2007

This Is Why Tony Romo Sucks

Take away the Tampa Bay blow out, Tony Romo is one of the worst QBs in the league.

Since I'm all about comparisons today, let's compare the performance of two QBs from last year.
QB 1
This Quarterback led his team deep into the playoffs (if I give you more details it will give it away), threw more touchdowns than interceptions in 9 of 16 games and finished the year with these stats:

262 / 480, 3193 yards, 23 Tds, 20 Ints, 4.2 Ints/Attempt

QB 2
This Quarterback led his team into the playoffs, threw more Touchdowns than interceptions in only 5 of his 11 starts (4 of 11 if you take away his fluke game) and finished the season with the following stat line if you take away his one absurd blowout on national TV that is the reason for all of the love thrown his way:

198 / 308, 2587 yds, 14Tds, 13 Ints, 4.2 Ints/Attempt

Other than completion percentage, these players had pretty similar stats. If you could name the worst QB in the league last year, who would you think of? I'll give you a second (again). You probably guessed Andrew Walter, well you're wrong but pretty close. Maybe Brett Favre? Nope, but closer. Hows about Eli Manning? No, but now you're real warm. Think about an angry and crazy fan base and a VERY good team. Got it? Yup, QB A is Rex Grossman. QB B then is Tony Romo if you take away the Tampa Bay Bucs game on Thanksgiving last year. Basically, without that game against the Bucs, Tony Romo is one of the worst QBs in the league. I'll get into this more deeply in a second, or now...

I hate Tony Romo. I really do. I do not hate the Cowboys but I do dislike them with a passion. They're the Yankees, Notre Dame and Duke; you either love em or hate em. I used to hate them but warmed up to them a bit because of Michael Irvin's fashion sense on Countdown every Sunday morning (a comically short tie goes a long way towards securing a place in my heart). My hatred of Romo in particular has to due with his undeserved ascension to Quarterback royalty within many circles in the football community. It's as if he took some fledgling franchise on his back and carried them to the promise land. When in fact he took a team many people had picked to win the Super Bowl and was 3-2 when took over and beat the Panthers, Cardinals, Bucs and Falcons (4 of the 6 worst teams in the NFL), and was AWFUL in the two wins they pulled out over the Giants and Colts. He was 1-3 against the NFC East, and in only one of those games did he have more TDs than Ints (and it wasn't the game he won). Not only that but in a key game against Philly in week 16, he put together an almost historically bad performance when it counted the most. And this was all before he blew the playoff game (a game in which he again was playing horribly before he fucked it all up). So even if we give him the Tampa Bay game, he did not have a great year last year. But we are not giving him the Tampa Bay game and it really needs to be looked at with a grain of salt so that Romo's season can be exposed for what it really is: A fucking disgrace.

On Thanksgiving Day, the Dallas Cowboys sha-fucking-lacked the Tampa Bay Bucs in Dallas. In the game, Tony Romo threw for 300+ yards, completed 75% of his passes, didn't get picked and had 5 Tds. A MONSTER performance. Really something. But how good was it? Well, as it turns out, the Bucs were probably the worst team in the NFL last year (you could argue Oakland was the worst but Oakland's defense was so good it's hard to argue that they were the overall worst). They had the third fewest Ints in the league, third fewest sacks in the league, gave up the second most passing TDs and ranked in the bottom of pretty much every pass defense stat you can think of. So it wasn't like he was competing agains the '85 Bears. But a closer look at the game itself reveals so much more about Romo's "transcendent" performance. Romo threw for touchdowns of 2 yards, 1 yard, 2 yards, 7 yards and 30 yards. Three were 2 yards or less and two were thrown when the game was clearly out of hand and probably wouldn't have been called if Parcells wasn't still trying to get a feel for his rookie QB's capabilities. And what he found is that up 20 pts, Tony Romo can complete a 2 yard pass. So this game that was apparently Tony Romo's coming out party was the equivalent of evaluating Brady Quinn's abilities after his performance against North Carolina or Air Force. To put it as clearly as possible, in a statistical sense, Romo's Tampa Bay game is the equivalent of Brady Anderson's 1996 season. It's because of this that I choose to evaluate Romo without taking into account the Tampa Bay game.

First, it's not as though Romo had a frickin banner year even with the absurd Tampa Bay game. The guy was in the bottom 50% for Int/Attempt, had 3 games where his passer rating was 58 or lower and lost to the Lions and the Skins. His saving grace was his completion percentage, which was amongst the highest in the league and accounts for his skewed status in the eyes of people who value that stat. But what is so striking is that when you take the Tampa game away from Romo, he doesn't just look average, he looks horrible. His QB rating (I know, I hate this stat but people use it) goes from 95.1 to 88.4. A seven point drop. No other QB in the league loses more than 3 points if you take away their best day. Romo goes from the middle of the road in terms of Int/attempts to bottom three, and his average ratio of 19 Tds to 13 Ints is horrendous at 14 and 13 if you take the Tampa game away. The best part is that even if you replace the Tampa game with an above average game for Romo (2tds and 1 Int), his final stats would still be horrendous at 16 Tds and 14 Ints. What I'm trying to make clear here is that not only is Tony Romo not a good QB, he's not even really average. And not only that, he had his best chance to succeed last year. It's not like this young buck can just put this behind him and get better, he's 27 and cocky as hell. He has reached his physical peak and is only going to get worse on that side. In terms of mental development, if he was going to learn something he was going to learn it from Parcells. With the easy going Wade Phillips running the show, Romo is in for a serious regression. Plus, who is going to lead that team, T.O.? This is why people weren't crazy when they were pissed that Big D didn't make a move for Quinn. Romo is not the future and he's hardly the past. He is simply not not good enough. And the sooner people realize that, the easier it will be to move on.

The QB Rating Is Ridiculous

This blackboard makes much more sense than the NFL's QB rating.

I'm gonna start by listing a stat set for three QBs and let you guess which one has the highest QB rating. I'm then going to tell you which one was the highest before I allow you to tell me your guess, thereby making useless your actual guess. Got it? Here goes

QB A
27/35, 280 yards, 3Tds, 6 Ints

QB B
27/35, 250 yards, 0Tds, 1 Int

QB C
25/48 305 yards, 3Tds, 1 Int

Ok, now you guess which Quarterback has the highest QB rating. You ready? I'll give you another second. Well to start, it's not QB B. His rating is the second highest (84.2). If that was your pick, pick again out of A or C. If you picked C, you are wrong. Pick again (just kidding. If you picked again, put your head down on your desk and nap it up for a little bit. The rest of this post may give you a headache.). So QB A, who threw for 5 more Ints and less yards than QB C while throwing the same amount of TDs as C, has a higher "rating" (88.7) than C (84.1). Well that makes sense, right? No, actually it doesn't at all.

The QB rating is often cited by broadcasters, pundits and "those in the know" as the defining statistic for Quarterbacks. It is a mysterious formula conceived by some stat dorks that attempts to compare how well Quarterbacks performed on a particular afternoon as well as over the course of the season. It is an "all-encompassing" statistic (the exact explanation can be found here) that takes into account percentage of completions per attempt, average yards gained per attempt, percentage of touchdown passes per attempt and percentage of interceptions per attempt. In reality, the QB rating is essentially a modified efficiency rating (as opposed to the college game's "QB Efficiency Rating". A comparison can be found here) and if it were used in the same vein as the college rating (to compare efficiency of the passing game) as opposed to the NFL's described more universal purpose:
The NFL rates its passers for statistical purposes against a fixed performance standard based on statistical achievements of all qualified pro passers since 1960. The current system replaced one that rated passers in relation to their position in a total group based on various criteria.

The current system, which was adopted in 1973, removes inequities that existed in the former method and, at the same time, provides a means of comparing passing performances from one season to the next....
I would have no problem with it. Instead the QB rating has morphed into this uber statistic by which all QBs are measured. Well I'm here to tell you that while it is a useful statistic to measure a QB's efficiency year in and year out, and is helpful in comparing how efficient different QBs are, it has little use beyond that and has no use in determining if one QB "performed" better than another in a given game, season or career.

One of the main problems with the QB rating is that it is too heavily weighted towards completion percentage and does not weight heavily enough interceptions. To illustrate this concern and because my first example went so well, allow me to give another example to help flush out my point:

QB A - 25/40, 300 yards, 3 Tds, 5 Ints = QB rating of 70.8

Let's give QB B +10 more completions:
QB B - 35/40, 300 yards, 3 Tds, 5 Ints = QB rating of 83.3

Now instead of the +10 completions, let's give QB C all of QB A's stats but give him -2 Ints:
QB C - 25/40, 300 yards, 3 Tds, 3 Ints = QB rating of 79.2

Interesting. So the yards were the same, the touchdowns were the same but because passer completed 10 more passes, QB B's rating is still higher than QB C's despite the fact that QB B through two more interceptions. QB B was more efficient, but is it really fair to say that a QB who threw 5 interceptions had a better day than a guy who threw 3 if the only thing he did better that day was complete more passes? Give me the 3 Int guy any day. Especially considering that in the NFL the team that wins the turnover battle has about an 75% chance of winning the game. And shouldn't a universal QB rating be a statistical reflection of the positive impact a passer has on his team's ability to win? I would think so. A quarterback's interceptions are far more impactful on a team's ability to win than 5 or 10 extra completions and should be weighted accordingly.

Another more common complaint about the rating is that the maximum rating you can possibly have is arbitrarily 158.33. As a matter of convenience and statistical aesthetics, I can understand the problem with it but this is coming from a country that measures distances in terms of 5280 feet when there's a perfectly reasonable system available that is a little more pleasing to the Ol' calculator. Where I do see this being a problem is that the maximum QB rating can be achieved whether a guy goes 5/5 for 80 yards and 1 td or 40/40 for 500 yards and 5 tds. That seems a little odd to me. A good rating would take into account the percentages as well as the cumulation of statistics. I don't think it should be possible to obtain a perfect rating.

A final problem that I have with the QB rating is that it doesn't take into account how much better than the average a QB is playing. One of the measurement factors I would take into account would be the deviation from the mean for all QBs across the league. I don't think you can have a QB rating without using a system that has built in comparisons for what is going on in the current season or is at least reflective of the historical percentages. For instance, if in a given year most QBs are throwing 1 or 2 tds per game and one or two guys are throwing 3 a game, that difference should be reflected in whatever rating is created to compare QBs. This is important in terms of historical context. If the rules change and in the future QBs are throwing 50 Tds per year consistently, a year like Peyton Manning had in 2004 won't be properly understood unless there is some stat to show how far above average he was that year. The QB rating is capable of just that type of comparison if properly created (I am likely not the man to do it, though I may give it a shot in the coming weeks).

In conclusion, the biggest problem I have with the NFL's QB rating is that people use it improperly. If you want to use it to show how efficient a QB has been in a game and how that efficiency has helped a team win, that's fine. If you want to use it to justify why one QB is better or has performed better over a given period of time, it's almost useless by itself. You need context. And any stat that cannot stand by itself isn't really worth using.